Presenter's Name:

Paper presented:

----------------------------------------------------------------

Technical Content

- Failed to present the technical material well
- Didn't cover the background, problem statement, approach, evaluation, etc.
  from the paper
- Figures poorly explained or not used when appropriate
- Presentation of technical material was too high-level
- Presentation of technical material was too detailed
- Incorrect analysis or interpretation of the data
- Mischaracterized related work
- Obvious strengths or problems in the paper not discussed
- Other issues are paper-specific...

----------------------------------------------------------------

Presentation

- Presentation was hard to follow
- Presentation was hard to read
- Unnumbered slides
- Halting or repetitive speech
- Failed to project voice
- Blocked the projector
- Fidgety body language
- Read from slides
- Material in slides not covered
- Spelling errors
- Bored the audience
- Wrong version of presentation
- Failed to repeat questions from the audience so everyone could hear
- Poor use of pointer
- Poor time management (talk too long or too short)

----------------------------------------------------------------

Bonuses

+ Good presentation of the context of the paper wrt other work
+ Incorporated external information from follow-on papers, cited papers, etc.
+ Good audience interaction (was a structured discussion, not a lecture)
+ Re-cast the author's explanations/figures/etc in a more understandable way
+ Provided more in-depth analysis or explanation than was provided in the
  paper